top of page

History Spotlight: Daniel Collins - A Pioneering Resident of Girard, Alabama

Writer: Historic Columbus
Historic Columbus
8 hours ago
7 min read

SOURCE: “Dreams Realized and Dreams Denied,” by Rod Hinton.  Muscogiana Journal, Fall 2019.


Rod's story highlights the dreams of Daniel Collins, who was one of the early pioneers in Girard, Alabama with ties to John Godwin and Horace King. The title of the article is seen through the hopes of Daniel Collins and the realities of Georgia's ownership over the rights to the Chattahoochee River.

 

In 2022, Rod graciously gave a lunch and lecture program for Historic Columbus on this topic. To view Rod's full lecture on the HCF YouTube channel, click here: https://youtu.be/jS6j9x295_c



Only known surviving image of Daniel Collins, courtesy of Rod Hinton.


Obituaries normally provide a window into an individual’s life. Some obituaries also tell the story of the time and place in which that individual lived. Dan Collins’ obituary does both, giving us a look at western expansion through the frontier towns of Columbus, Georgia and Girard, Alabama.


Collins was born in Cheraw, South Carolina in 1824, the son of Charles Collins, a native of Gloucester, Massachusetts and Lindymiry Edwards, a native of James River, Virginia. In 1834, at the age of ten, Dan arrived in the Columbus/Girard area with his family. His obituary describes the area as being “on the borders of civilization.” Collins’s brother James, in an 1889 interview with the Troy Messenger, pointed out that: “Their destination was Benton, now Calhoun County, Alabama, but on arriving at Columbus, Georgia, they learned that Indian troubles were brewing and consequently settled in Girard….”


An account of the funeral of Mr. Collins, which appeared in the Columbus Enquirer-Sun

on April 24, 1901.


Traveling through Columbus to get to Benton (Calhoun) County, Alabama, from Cheraw, South Carolina does not, on the surface, make sense. Staying in Girard because there was Indian trouble in Benton is equally puzzling. This route was not the shortest or the safest route and there were also conflicts between the earlier settlers and the Creek Indians in this part of Alabama. In his interview with the Messenger, James Collins described how six Indians were hanged near the creek in Girard for ambushing a stage on the Federal Road and killing “the driver and all of the passengers except one.” He also recalled how “… often the family would have to arise in the night and make haste to the Georgia side of the river, the ringing of the bells the signal to flee.” One of Collins’s great-grandchildren later described how the local Creeks would often verbalize their firm belief that Girard “…would wash away as a curse for (their land) being taken from them.”


Understanding Charles Collin’s background does not provide an exact answer as to why he traveled this way in 1834, but it does provide some clues. Cheraw, where Charles had come from, was also where craftsman John Godwin had lived and worked prior to arriving in Columbus in 1832. Godwin ventured to the city to build an Ithiel Town-style lattice bridge across the Chattahoochee River. Charles, a carpenter, was originally from New England where the lattice style of covered bridge had been developed. Noted bridge builder Ithiel Town introduced his method of bridge building to the South in 1824, when he supervised the building of a bridge on the Pee Dee River in Cheraw. Town’s work in Cheraw significantly impacted Godwin, both in his knowledge of construction methods and the direction of his career. An understanding of how to build a lattice-style bridge might explain why Charles moved from New England to Cheraw and the possibility that he already had a working relationship with John Godwin might explain why he traveled this way and remained for a period of time.


1837 map of the southeast by J. Olney showing the Cheraw region of South Carolina, Benton County, Alabama, and Columbus. Courtesy of the David Rumsey Map Collection.


This possibility is supported by the knowledge that Charles Collins eventually left Girard to become a bridge keeper in Tallapoosa County, Alabama, sometime between 1840 and 1850. John Godwin and Horace King had built a bridge at Tallassee in Tallapoosa County in 1837 for landowners who had also moved to Alabama from the Cheraw area. This bridge was severely damaged during the “Harrison Freshet,” a flood which coincided with the inauguration of President William Henry Harrison in 1841. It was rebuilt by Horace King, most likely in 1845.


Dan Collins was the only descendent of Charles to permanently remain in Girard. His obituaries describe him as a successful and respected man who witnessed, and was part of, the significant growth that occurred in the surrounding area. One obituary notes that he was “… one of Girard’s most prominent and progressive citizens up to the time of his death.” Another obituary states that: “He was well known and well-liked by the residents of the three cities and is a landmark who will be sadly missed.” They also tell of the tremendous difficulties that had to be overcome living there and describe how, in the end, he had to accept the fact that his dream of Girard becoming an industrial rival to Columbus would never be realized.


After his arrival in the region in the 1830s, Dan Collins built a home for his family in Girard, where it still stands today. While he remained in Girard the rest of his life, he would actually work across the river most of his career. Early on, he worked as a pattern maker, within the Columbus Iron Works organization. A Columbus Daily Enquirer article in 1865 noted that he was “… capable of bringing out of wood a pattern of the most exquisite and difficult draught, from the common cooking utensil to the ponderous steam cylinder.” The author further stated that: “Truly it is a pleasure to view the beautiful workmanship of his hands.” For many years thereafter he ran a fixture manufacturing business located across from Empire Mills at the corner of Front and Thomas, now 9th Street. According to the city directory and advertisements he placed in the local newspapers, he and his sons produced furniture, blinds, doors, sashes, and similar wooden products.


The Columbus and Girard waterfront, with Godwin and King’s covered bridge in the background, as it might have appeared at Collin’s time. Pont de Columbus, by Francis de la Porte, Collection of The Columbus Museum, Courtesy of The Columbus Museum.


Dan Collins was also credited with participating in the building of virtually every steamboat constructed in Columbus during the years of his career. His skills in building steamboats were not limited to carpentry. In 1869, he was granted a patent for an improvement in the balance valve used in steam engines. The last steamboat he built was the Bessie Clary. He was both engineer and builder of that vessel, which he designed uniquely to function when water levels on the river were low.


As a resident of Girard, Collins was involved in creating a functioning town out of what had been the home of the Creeks as well as the outlaws who took advantage of this frontier territory as a refuge from the legal processes that had been established across the river in Georgia. In 1834, the same year Collins arrived with his family, the Irish stage actor Tyrone Power traveled through the area, describing it as: “… a wild-looking village, scattered through the edge of the forest, bearing the unattractive name of Sodom [just south of what became Girard]; few of its denizens were yet stirring; they are composed chiefly of ‘minions o’ the moon,’ outlaws from the neighboring states. Gamblers, and other desperate men, here find security from their numbers, and from the vicinity of a thinly inhabited Indian country, whose people hold them in terror, yet dare not refuse them a hiding-place.”


Taming this frontier was a very difficult task but it was not the most frustrating battle Collins and his fellow Girard pioneers faced. Men like Stephen Ingersoll and John Godwin worked hard to create an industrial base on the Alabama side of the river. Among their many endeavors, Godwin built a warehouse at the mouth of Holland Creek and Ingersoll built an early dam and mill on the Alabama side of the Chattahoochee, just north of the current pedestrian bridge at 14th Street.


Steamboat Bessie Clary, from Perilous Journeys: A History of Steamboating on the Chattahoochee, Apalachicola, and Flint Rivers, 1828-1928, by Edward A. Mueller.


Unfortunately for these entrepreneurs, the high water mark on the Alabama side of the Chattahoochee had been legally established as the Georgia border, in effect bringing the Girard waterfront under the jurisdiction of another state. Then, in 1840, the state of Georgia granted Columbus the right to sell what were referred to as the “Water Lots” on the city’s riverfront. The purchasers of these lots were given all rights associated with the lots, extending across the river to the high water mark on the western bank. These entrepreneurs, mostly Columbusites, became diligent in their commitment to controlling how the river was used. Subsequently, Godwin and his partners were denied the right to build a steamboat dock on the river, rendering his warehouse useless, except as a religious meeting place. As early as 1838, he allowed a Methodist congregation, including Collins’ wife, to meet in this building. They continued meeting there until 1851, when they built a permanent church building.


In return for being sold the Water Lots in Columbus, the initial owners were obligated to build a raceway and dam designed to move the flow of the Chattahoochee from the Alabama side of the river to the Columbus riverbank, allowing mills to be constructed there. Eventually, this effort led to another conflict over control of the river, this one centering on the operation of Ingersoll’s mill.


Ingersoll’s use of the river was challenged in the courts of both Georgia and Alabama until it was finally resolved in favor of Columbus by the U.S. Supreme Court during their December session of 1851. “The Court affirmed that only the Georgia riverbank owners enjoyed riparian rights. Unable to use the river, Girard never became a commercial or manufacturing center; it remained a suburb or a bedroom community rather than a rival to Columbus.”



This decision was the final blow to the dreams of the settlers of Girard. One of Dan Collins’ obituaries states that: “Mr. Collins has seen the endeavor of Girard to outrival Columbus as a city and has seen her become an important suburb of her one-time rival.” Another obituary, states that: “Mr. Collins was always a firm believer in the future of Girard and only in recent years did he give up the idea, even though still hoping to see it become an important town.” Today, many of the industrial structures on the Georgia side of the river are proudly preserved. The Alabama side is also preserved but in its natural state, which is beautiful, but in stark contrast to the Georgia side. Together these opposing river banks represent both “dreams realized and dreams denied.”

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page